Guide
MCB vs MCCB vs ACB: how to choose a circuit breaker
A plain comparison of the three breaker families and the details a supplier needs to quote the right one.
Electrical RFQs often ask for “breakers” without saying which family. MCBs, MCCBs and ACBs overlap in purpose but differ in size, rating and where they sit in an installation. This guide compares them using a published trade-body guide and manufacturer explanations.
The three families
MCB stands for miniature circuit breaker, MCCB for moulded case circuit breaker and ACB for air circuit breaker. All three interrupt current when it exceeds a set level. They differ in how much current they carry, how much fault current they can interrupt, and how their trip settings are adjusted.
Comparison
The BEAMA guide to low voltage circuit breakers gives these typical ranges.
- MCB: about 0.5 A to 125 A, short-circuit rating up to 25 kA, fixed protection settings, used on final circuits such as sockets and lighting. Covered by BS EN 60898, which is based on IEC 60898.
- MCCB: about 16 A to 1,600 A, up to 3,200 A available, short-circuit rating up to 100 kA, fixed or adjustable settings, typically near the supply transformer or on sub-mains. Covered by BS EN 60947-2, based on IEC 60947-2.
- ACB: about 630 A to 6,300 A, short-circuit rating up to 150 kA, adjustable settings including time delays, used as main incoming protection. Also under BS EN 60947-2.
Manufacturer articles give slightly different ranges, so treat these as typical bands and not as limits for a specific product.
Breaking capacity terms
Two terms appear on datasheets.
- Icu, rated ultimate short-circuit breaking capacity: tested with an open-close-open sequence. The prospective fault current at the point of installation should not exceed it unless the manufacturer specifies back-up protection.
- Ics, rated service short-circuit breaking capacity: tested with a longer sequence, applies to faults that could occur in practice, and tells you the breaker can remain in service after interrupting a fault up to that level. Under the standard Ics must be at least 25% of Icu.
For an MCB, the standard uses Icn, rated short-circuit capacity, and Ics is derived from Icn by a factor.
Curves, poles and trip units
- MCB curves B, C and D set the trip response. Lighting and general loads, motors and transformers usually need different curves.
- Poles: 1P, 2P, 3P or 4P. State whether the neutral must be switched.
- MCCB trip units: thermal-magnetic units give adjustable thermal and magnetic thresholds. Electronic units add more settings.
RCCB, ELCB, isolators and contactors
A breaker protects against overload and short circuit. Residual current devices detect earth leakage and an isolator only disconnects. The old catalogue lists residual current breakers, isolators and contactors separately from MCBs and MCCBs. Make sure the RFQ names the exact function you need.
A short worked example
A small workshop distribution board feeds sockets, lighting and a 22 kW motor. The sockets and lighting sit on MCBs, because the circuits are small and the protection settings are fixed. The motor feeder is larger, so the designer chooses an MCCB with a thermal-magnetic trip unit. The incoming supply uses a larger breaker sized for the whole board. The example only shows how the three families split the job, and your engineer chooses the actual ratings from load calculations and the fault level at the board.
Common mistakes in breaker orders
- Replacing a breaker with the same rated current and ignoring breaking capacity.
- Mixing up residual current devices and breakers. They do different jobs.
- Ordering an isolator when protection is needed.
- Forgetting that a 3-pole breaker does not switch the neutral.
- Ignoring the ambient temperature of the panel, which affects the rating on the datasheet.
Questions to ask any supplier
- What are Icu and Ics for the offered model?
- Is the trip unit adjustable?
- Which accessories fit this frame?
- Which standard does the datasheet cite?
- Is the model the one named in the design, or an equivalent, and on what basis?
How to specify a breaker
- Family and function: MCB, MCCB, ACB, RCCB or isolator
- Rated current in amps and the number of poles
- Breaking capacity in kA and the standard you work to
- Trip curve for an MCB, or trip unit type for an MCCB
- Brand preference or “equivalent”
- Accessories such as auxiliary contacts, shunt trips or handles
- Quantity, delivery site and date
Send the list to request an MCCB or breaker quote. Breaker selection for an installation is a design decision for a qualified electrical engineer. This page explains the terms and does not replace that design.
What this guide does not do
It does not claim that any breaker we quote meets a standard or fits your installation. Ask for the datasheet for the exact model offered and have your engineer confirm it.
Ready to quote?
Send the item, specification, quantity and delivery location. Open the quote form with this topic filled in, or email sales@vmv-solutions.com.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use an MCCB in place of an MCB?
Not automatically. They differ in size, mounting and ratings. Ask an electrical engineer to confirm the replacement against the circuit's rating and fault level.
What is the difference between Icu and Ics?
Icu is the ultimate short-circuit breaking capacity and Ics the service capacity, the level after which the breaker can stay in service. Ics is often given as a percentage of Icu.
What do the B, C and D curves mean?
They describe how quickly an MCB trips on overload and on short circuit. Match the curve to the load, for example motors and transformers need a different curve from lighting.
How many poles do I need?
Poles depend on the supply: one, two, three or four. State pole count and whether the neutral needs to be switched.
Do you show breaker prices?
No. Every breaker is quoted from the rating, poles, brand preference and quantity you send.
Sources
BEAMA: guide to low voltage circuit breakers | Schneider Electric: 5 differences between MCB and MCCB | Schneider Electric blog: IEC 60898-1 and IEC 60947-2
